CREATIVITY IS YOUR EDGE.
Balancing Art and Commerce.
Whilst navigating the complex and hyper-competitive Australian designer fashion industry for over two decades, Alexandra constantly walked the tightrope between beauty and the business, the magic and maths, and design and data, steering the brand towards commercial success whilst fulfilling a clear artistic direction. She shares insights about the importance of maintaining this equilibrium within all business sectors.
The GINGER + SMART story traversed many a success and its fair share of failures. Over a 20-year journey, the brand took off from my dining room table and landed in Saks 5th Ave in NYC. Through this lived-experience, I have learned how to help established entrepreneurs and business leaders harness strategies to optimise their enterprises with a sense of fulfilment, not solely measured by net profit.
Most business leaders possess a bias toward either commerciality or creativity, rarely both. This is a problem because commerciality without creativity means you have no point of difference (so why would anyone buy your product or seek your services?) and creativity without commercial success results in poor financial gain.
At GINGER + SMART, when we leaned too far towards product design and development (sketching, pattern making, print and fabric sourcing through to planning runway collection shows) the control of the business and its processes, resources and profitability were compromised.
Yet if we leaned too far towards a commercial focus (inventory spreadsheets, freight and logistics, staffing and resourcing) we lost our unique differentiation, edge and purpose.
When leaders combine creative and commercial thinking in their business strategy and operations, a world of exciting outcomes opens up, beyond productivity and profits. Getting it right, finding the intersection, is what truly enables greatness.
Here’s how to find that optimal balance, and in turn, the magic:
Determine what creative thinking is within your business.
It’s a fluency of ideation and ideas, imagination, design and boundless creative thought. It’s a multi-dimensional process of inquiry to unearth originality. It’s about adopting different approaches and ways of doing things and being open to change. To arrive here requires trialling and testing, verification, sampling and embracing contradictions. And it often requires failing until you find your sweet spot.
Creative thinking can manifest in all aspects of life and enterprise, not just products and services but marketing, logistics, finance, risk and governance. Essentially, it’s about big, bold ideas, forward-thinking and conceptualising, outside-of-the-box interactions, partnerships and collaborations, openness to hard feedback and acceptance of change. The journey certainly is not linear. It can be messy. And it isn’t easy. In the case of Ginger & Smart, as is expected of a fashion brand, we had to be one step ahead of the customer and anticipate what she didn’t know she even wanted yet!
(Full disclosure: it requires patience, trust, acceptance of people changing their minds – often – and conviction. Be prepared for difficult conversations. Take the leap).
Now let's define commerciality
No real surprises here. Initially driven by a sink-or-swim survival mentality, it’s all about the principles, practices and the spirit of commerce. It encompasses business, enterprise, HR, sales, goals, KPIs, outcomes, finance and freight, shared services and production. It’s the ‘reality’, most often measured by profitability and ‘success’.
Practical business minds often grapple with the free-flowing creative edge just as creatives often struggle with the practicalities of commerciality. The serious dilemma, indeed risk, for leaders and organisations is that most don't engage or commit adequately towards an intersection of the two.
The payoff for finding the right balance between creativity and commerce is the key to driving value. It’s the ultimate merging of the left brain (logic and numbers) and right brain (innovation and intuition). It’s a tension, but it's healthy pain, because when the balance is found and maintained, then magic can happen.
Research* tells us that 64% of leaders do not think creatively or with an entrepreneurial mindset when it comes to decision-making. Fixed on to their ways of doing things, their approach hampers potential. This presents a serious opportunity for individuals and organisations to disrupt and add value with open thinking.
Further, evidence** tells us that when organisations commit to emboldening creativity there are many tangible benefits including attracting the best talent, developing a culture of trust supported by well-being, increasing motivation and therefore productivity, improving engagement with clients, and ultimately, increasing profitability.
But a successful enterprise must be supported by a culture that celebrates and enables both creativity and commerciality underpinned by disruption, collaboration and conviction in equal doses to drive both. Leaders need to see the creative thinkers in their organisation adding value equal to the commercial thinkers and encourage them to collaborate by uniting their unique perspectives. This integrative thinking is only possible if the culture allows it. And it comes from the top.
Yet leaders are challenged by myriad pain points including fear of disruption, lack of ESG planning, slow decision-making processes, risk of reputation, declining customer engagement, very real burnout, diminishing rates of resilience and motivation, and keeping talent.
Here’s how leaders can walk the tightrope:
+ Enable strong supported/supportive leadership
+ Get comfortable with being uncomfortable and embracing the messiness of creativity
+ Build a culture that supports collaboration and openness
+ Encourage entrepreneurial thinking (a big one)
+ Build trust across teams and individuals
+ Enable flexible thinking and delivery
+ Insist on great communication
+ Build resilience amongst teams with well-being practices
In any business, it’s not easy to strike the often elusive balance between beauty and business, the magic and the maths, and design and data. Running a thriving creative enterprise is a balancing act. It requires an active and keen awareness of how developed its leaders are. And just like the way there is often a keen eye on risk, an organisation needs to develop the resources and time and focus given to both creativity and business… lean too far in either direction and it's a long, and quick, way to the bottom.
* Change the Way You Persuade - Harvard Business Review, 2005
** Creativity: The Commercial Superpower, Barker Langham 2019